Tue. Apr 28th, 2026

Mike Nolan

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 3,586 through 3,600 (of 7,932 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: What are you Baking the Week of June 6, 2021? #30223
    Mike Nolan
    Keymaster

      As a reminder, facts, like a list of ingredients, cannot be copyrighted.

      What is copyrightable with regards to a recipe are the instructions. Even then it is the specific wording that is copyrighted, not the intent.

      I find it is useful to know the provenance of a recipe, if only because that often tells you a lot about what went into its creation. Jim Lahey gets a lot of credit for the NY Times no-knead bread recipe, but it appears no-knead recipes had been around for decades. Lahey improved the recipe, clarified the instructions, and popularized the concept, and all of those are worth giving credit for.

      The rule of thumb I've always heard is that if you change 3 ingredients in a recipe (different ingredients or significantly different amounts), then it is considered a new recipe. I still find it helpful to know its background, though.

      in reply to: Extra Large Sheet Pan #30177
      Mike Nolan
      Keymaster

        We used a roll-in convection oven for my SFBI pastry course and the instructions they gave us have you do it in a convection oven, but I find it works better if I do just the first half or so on convection mode. I often put a pie shield on top after the changeover to keep the edges from getting too dark.

        It took me about a half dozen pies to work out the settings that work best for me. Every oven is just a little different.

        in reply to: Extra Large Sheet Pan #30175
        Mike Nolan
        Keymaster

          Not sure where I read it, but I think you want at least a half inch on the front and back (the back rack usually gives you that) and an inch on each side wall. Having a true circulation fan (with separate air inlets and outlets) would impact that, but I'm pretty sure all the 'convection' fan in my big oven does is blow air across the top. That's probably enough to encourage more circulation providing there are adequate air channels around the pans.

          About the only thing I use the convection setting for is for the first 10-15 minutes of pies, then I drop the temp and put it on regular oven mode. I find the time at a higher temp (and with the fan on) gets the crust properly done.

          in reply to: Extra Large Sheet Pan #30170
          Mike Nolan
          Keymaster

            The next time I'm in Pittsburgh I'll probably try to make a trip to Penn Fixtures and Supplies, and I'll see if they still carry a 3/4 sheet pan. I suspect the ones they had were Winware, but it has been several years since I bought one.

            I've been looking at flip boards lately, they seem to come in two sizes, 18 inch and 24 inch.

            in reply to: What are you Baking the Week of May 30, 2021? #30161
            Mike Nolan
            Keymaster

              They're good, but so far no 2 batches have come out quite the same, one was too soft in the middle, two were a bit too hard in the middle (the last one about as hard as biscotti), one was probably scorched on the bottom, the first batch was the best so far. I'm going to drop the temperature 25 degrees for the next one.

              But if I keep making the ChallaPrince's challah recipe, I'll probably keep making these cookies because he has you use an egg yolk wash on them, and this is a quick way to use up the egg whites.

              in reply to: What are you Baking the Week of May 30, 2021? #30156
              Mike Nolan
              Keymaster

                When I have left over egg whites from Challah, I've been making 'forgotten' chocolate meringue cookies, a Washington Post recipe. I've made 4 batches of them, no 2 of them came out quite the same. Next batch I'm going to lower the temperature a bit, I think the cocoa got a little scorched in the last batch.

                in reply to: What are you Cooking the Week of May 30, 2021? #30155
                Mike Nolan
                Keymaster

                  We had the last of the French onion soup that wasn't put in the freezer. I used challah as the bread in the first batch, this one used semolina bread, which is better because the challah is just a bit too sweet.

                  in reply to: What are you Baking the Week of May 30, 2021? #30129
                  Mike Nolan
                  Keymaster

                    I thought it looked a bit too dark until I read the part about the cinnamon, looks tasty.

                    in reply to: Extra Large Sheet Pan #30119
                    Mike Nolan
                    Keymaster

                      2/3 and 3/4 sized pans are not that common, but the 3/4 pan fits my big oven much better than a full sheet pan does, because there's almost no room for the air to circulate around a full sheet pan.

                      in reply to: Extra Large Sheet Pan #30116
                      Mike Nolan
                      Keymaster

                        These look like they may be similar to the pans I have:
                        16x22 sheet pan

                        One of the problem with the 2/3 and 3/4 size pans is that nobody seems to make a raised grid/cooling rack designed to fit in them.

                        in reply to: What are you Baking the Week of May 30, 2021? #30113
                        Mike Nolan
                        Keymaster

                          Today I'm planning to make a batch of bagels.

                          in reply to: Extra Large Sheet Pan #30112
                          Mike Nolan
                          Keymaster

                            I have 3/4 sized sheet pans (they're about 15 3/4 by 21 3/4) that I get from a restaurant supply store in Pittsburgh (Penn Fixture and Supplies), they are on the web and do mail order. Never had them warp on high heat. Vollrath pans should work in high heat, too. You want pans with an edge that's rolled around a wire frame, that keeps them from warping.

                            in reply to: Rosetta Roll Experiments #30106
                            Mike Nolan
                            Keymaster

                              These rolls are fairly popular in Italy, using a pasta roller would probably make them too time-consuming.

                              in reply to: Rosetta Roll Experiments #30095
                              Mike Nolan
                              Keymaster

                                I don't think they're supposed to be THAT hollow, but there's probably a large variance from one baker to another.

                                in reply to: What are you Baking the Week of May 23, 2021? #30087
                                Mike Nolan
                                Keymaster

                                  I like a little semolina in pizza dough, but if you put in too much it changes the flavor profile and texture, corn meal does that too.

                                  We haven't done a pizza lately, just hasn't sounded good.

                                Viewing 15 posts - 3,586 through 3,600 (of 7,932 total)